Why I Stopped Eating Meat

I love meat. Most of my favourite food experiences have included meat of some variety, whether it be the chicken, mutton and other meats used in the curries I ate in India, the delicious barbecue pork I’ve had amongst Americans or the amazing flavours of the Brazillian churascos. I see meat eaten every day, and I want it.

The thing about vegetarianism is that it doesn’t necessarily mean you don’t enjoy meat, and that you don’t want it – you just choose not to give into that temptation.

I’m learning to recognize my cravings for what they are: my stomach saying “feed me” and my thoughts turning to foods I have become used to craving at such times. 90+% of the time, I find that a delicious vegetarian dish will be every bit as satisfying by the time that I’m done eating, even if I had been craving meat before that.

My journey to vegetarianism has seemed somewhat abrupt, but has been coming for a while. For over a year now I’ve become more and more interested in what industrial farming has done to our food. There was a big part of me that did not want to know, because it might lead to a seemingly large sacrifice.
MLE read all of the books we had purchased on the subject. I shared her enthusiasm for the subject hesitantly – enough to know a lot of bad stuff was going on, but not really prepared to delve into it. I has horrified at the things she described, but guiltily wanted her to stop telling me.
To reassure myself, I began to take the position that we should avoid factory farmed meats and buy from local food sources. We’re poor, and the idea of spending an extra few dollars per pound of meat seemed daunting at first, but when you consider that the average Australian/American eats much more meat than they need to, we figured we’d eat better and eat less.

Don’t get me wrong. This is a good approach. It recognizes the cruelty and injustice inherent in the industrial farming system where big corporations are willing to sacrifice animal and human well-being for profit (a great introduction to this is the movie Food Inc). I know a lot of people who take this approach and their diets are undoubtedly better for doing it.

What helped me to make the decision to stop eating meat altogether was a conversation with MLE (who urged me to consider the matter further) which led to me reading the book Why We Love Dogs, Eat Pigs, and Wear Cows: An Introduction to Carnism. Not only was this my first step into learning the grotesque details of factory farming, but it asked the question: What goes on in the human mind to make one animal a pet and another animal food?
It describes the dominant philosophical approach to the question as “Carnism” and compares it to patriarchy in that it is a position so ubiquitous within society we don’t readily recognize it. As science leads us to understand that there are few nutrients that we can get from meat alone, the slaughter of billions of lives every year has become unnecessary.

I began discussing the questions I was dealing with on facebook and received some useful feedback. It was helpful to understand that plants can also suffer, and to see it from the perspective that all life relies on the destruction of other life for its survival. In the end though, I came to the conclusion that while plant life can suffer, animals can think and build relationships and experience emotion (including the terror of impending death).

I have taken this step as an act of faith. Consistency of action with belief has been something I have admired greatly in others, and I have decided to pursue it myself. As my beliefs cause me to grieve over the suffering that exists in the world, I need to live a life that reduces that suffering and promotes the most good.

On top of this, I have learned more about what it is to sacrifice. I have sacrificed most of my favourite foods for a greater good. I have recognized that the life within a cow, a chicken, a pig or a fish carries more worth to me than eating those foods. I also now take more time to recognize that whatever I eat causes the end of something’s life. In doing that, in preparation for eating I prayerfully recognize that a sacrifice of life has been made, that I might have strength and life to do some good in the world. I figure that if my life is going to be extended by the killing of other life, I had better not live wastefully.

This is also the most counter-cultural thing I’ve ever done in my life. It has really brought to me a sense of being ‘in the world, but not of it’. There is a certain awkwardness that comes with eating vegetarian. Most restaurants do not cater to you with more than a couple of dishes. There is also a noticeable difference between how people respond to your food choices. When you eat a non-meat dish without identifying as vegetarian it’s no big deal. For some, it seems like my choice to eat that same dish becomes more threatening when I identify myself as vegetarian.
I have greatly appreciated the support where we have received it, but have been somewhat surprised as some people just seem to wish we would be “normal” again.

Overall, I’ve found it to be one of the most worthwhile and meaningful decisions I have made. I understand the impact of my daily life with increased clarity, and it has felt like a major step toward becoming the more consistent Christian I have long intended to be.

Most of the people I have talked to about where meat comes from recognize that there are some terrible things that go on in meat production, as I have. Many don’t want to know the details because it would cost them the enjoyment of treasured foods, as I did.
I encourage you to learn the facts. Ignoring problems don’t make them go away. For those who choose to eat meat, I encourage you to find local sources of meat and animal products (in America Local Harvest is a great source). Most of us could eat less and eat better.

When you come across vegetarians, be supportive – chances are they are taking a difficult action based upon deeply held beliefs.

Grace:
Creator of all,
We give thanks for the miracle of life and honour the life sacrificed in the preparation of our meal.
May we eat giving thanks, committing to use the energy and life we draw from this sacrifice for the good of the world, that we might create with you a world in which your gifts to us are honoured always.

Amen.

Advertisements

3 responses to “Why I Stopped Eating Meat

  1. Very insightful and admirable, Rick. I’m not ready to read the books yet, but if I did, I’d probably end up where you’ve arrived. How does one make sure the meat they eat was treated well? Funny as it may seem, the unethical treatment of animals has loomed in the back of my mind ever since: 1) seeing the Napoleon Dynamite chicken farm scene (which isn’t even grotesque, I just remember the chickens being tightly caged) AND 2) reading about Temple Grandin re-doing slaughter houses to make them less traumatic for the animals. Best wishes on your veggie tales journey.

  2. Hi Rick,
    Here are some other really great reasons to be vegetarian, to add to your animal ethics issue above:
    1. Its extremely healthy, and is known to be associated with much better long-term health outcomes. Vegetarian diets are anti-inflammatory, anti-oxidant, and therefore protective against many chronic diseases such as cancer, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and obesity (As long as you avoid the pitfall of compensating animal protein with too many carbohydrates).
    2. Vegetarian diets have long been associated with spiritual clarity, and the ability to more deeply engage in meditation, prayer, and other transcendent states of being.
    3. Vegetarian diets are cheaper than meat based diets – when done properly (Eg: not buying highly processed ‘replacement’ products such as vegeburgers and soycheese). And in my opinion, probably the most compelling reason:
    4. Vegetarian diets are far more sustainable than meat based diets. Vegetarian proteins are so much more environmentally economical to produce, in terms of resource consumption. Soy crops are 20 times more efficient in terms of total protein output than beef production. So as an overpopulated globe, we can’t afford the environmental resources to be consuming a lot of animal protein. Lifetime vegetarians seem to be much smaller people too. Meat does encourage growth, creating a population that is getting taller and taller – and overall will require a much higher food per person over the course of their lifetime. Another reason why vegetarian diets create a more sustainable food solution for our expanding population.

    However, beware the pitfalls:
    1. Women in particular need to keep check on their iron & B12 levels. Most women are anaemic or borderline even when they do eat meat. Supplementation is wise in these cases, and in times of pregnancy and lactation it is wise to listen to your body requirements to avoid malnourishment and illness in mother and child.
    2. Substituting meat with carbohydrates can lead to major malnourishment in the form of protein deficiency. Understanding protein combining is essential and must be followed at every meal.
    3. Not everyone can handle it. I’m sure you know about the blood group diet. O blood types, particularly woman, can really struggle to stay well on a vegetarian diet, and so following all the other recommendations of the blood group diet, besides the meat, may help to overcome the absence of animal protein.
    4. Borrow recipes from naturally vegetarian cultures. Creating vegetarian versions of Western food usually results in a poorly balanced, and not too tasty, meals.
    5. Remember to keep an eye on your Iron, B12 & zinc levels. And ensure you have protein with every meal. Otherwise your immune system (like mine) will crash.

    I have had several attempts at vegetarianism, all of which have seen me chronically ill. However, now that I’m over the major hump of pregnancy and breastfeeding, our household has gone to a semi-vegetarian state where we don’t eat red meat (or rarely) and have complete vegetarian days at least 3 days a week. Eventually we will try to phase across completely, but as an entirly O blood family, we’re just trying to stay well in the process.

    Good luck!

    Annie

  3. Thanks Heather and Annie for the supportive posts, and thanks Annie for the advice.

    We’ve been on a semi-vegetarian diet for about a year now. In Kirtland we would eat mostly vegetarian food when cooking at home, and mostly ate meat when eating with other people or when eating out. Moving to Boise, and with Boise having a strong culture of eating out, we initially resisted adopting a fully vegetarian diet. We finally concluded we should just do it anyway.
    Other than removing meat from my diet, the main difference to what I eat is that I’m increasing my consumption of beans, lentils, etc (for protein) and leafy greens (for iron).
    Initially, I thought about carefully planning meals to ensure all the nutrients would be there. Then I realized that I didn’t do that when I was eating meat. So I’m being conscious to try to increase my intake of the things I’m losing by not eating meat, but also not so careful as to drive myself (and my wife) crazy.

    By the way, my blood type is B+, so I’m B(eing) positive about the prospects of vegetarian living. 😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s